ansible-cmdb vs Ansible Semaphore

Struggling to choose between ansible-cmdb and Ansible Semaphore? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

ansible-cmdb is a Network & Admin solution with tags like documentation, inventory, configuration-management.

It boasts features such as Generates documentation from Ansible inventory, Documents system configuration, networking, installed software, Provides visualization of infrastructure relationships, Integrates with Ansible playbooks and roles, Supports multiple output formats like HTML, Markdown, JSON, Open source and easy to extend and pros including Automatic documentation from existing Ansible inventory, No need to maintain separate documentation, Visualization helps understand infrastructure, Free and open source, Active development community.

On the other hand, Ansible Semaphore is a Development product tagged with ansible, automation, configuration-management, devops.

Its standout features include Web-based UI for managing Ansible, Role-based access control, Playbook repository, Playbook scheduling, Inventory management, Playbook execution and monitoring, REST API, and it shines with pros like Open source and free, Easy to install and configure, Good for small teams, Active development community, Integrates well with Ansible.

Feature	ansible-cmdb	Ansible Semaphore
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Network & Admin	Development

Product Overview

ansible-cmdb

Description: Ansible-cmdb is an open source tool that generates documentation for IT environments based on Ansible inventory. It automatically documents system configuration, networking, installed software, and more in around 60 words.

Ansible Semaphore

Description: Ansible Semaphore is an open source alternative to Ansible Tower that provides a web-based user interface and REST API for managing Ansible playbooks. It allows you to easily run Ansible playbooks and view detailed logs without needing direct access to Ansible.

Key Features Comparison

ansible-cmdb Features

• Generates documentation from Ansible inventory
• Documents system configuration, networking, installed software
• Provides visualization of infrastructure relationships
• Integrates with Ansible playbooks and roles
• Supports multiple output formats like HTML, Markdown, JSON
• Open source and easy to extend

Ansible Semaphore Features

• Web-based UI for managing Ansible
• Role-based access control
• Playbook repository
• Playbook scheduling
• Inventory management
• Playbook execution and monitoring
• REST API

Pros & Cons Analysis

ansible-cmdb

Pros

• Automatic documentation from existing Ansible inventory
• No need to maintain separate documentation
• Visualization helps understand infrastructure
• Free and open source
• Active development community

Cons

• Limited out-of-the-box documentation
• Additional customization required for comprehensive docs
• Not a full IT documentation solution
• Limited to environments managed by Ansible

Ansible Semaphore

Pros

• Open source and free
• Easy to install and configure
• Good for small teams
• Active development community
• Integrates well with Ansible

Cons

• Lacks some advanced features of Ansible Tower
• Not ideal for large enterprises
• Limited native integrations with 3rd party tools
• Less polished UI than Tower
• Limited support options

Pricing Comparison

ansible-cmdb

• Open Source

Ansible Semaphore

• Open Source