Edgecam vs DeskProto

Struggling to choose between Edgecam and DeskProto? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Edgecam is a Development solution with tags like cad, cam, cnc, machining, milling, turning, wire-edm, toolpath-programming.

It boasts features such as CAD file import and model preparation, Toolpath programming for milling, turning, wire EDM, etc., Accurate machining simulation, Post-processing of G-code and pros including Powerful toolpath programming capabilities, Supports many machine tool types and operations, Integrates CAD and CAM in one package, Helpful simulation features.

On the other hand, DeskProto is a Development product tagged with cad, cam, cnc, milling, machining, toolpath, gcode.

Its standout features include Imports various 3D file formats like STL, OBJ, 3DS, VRML, STEP, IGES, etc., Supports 3-axis and 5-axis CNC milling, Generates optimized toolpaths for roughing and finishing operations, Simulates toolpaths to detect collisions and other issues, Supports various post-processors for outputting G-code, Includes a customizable CAM editor for modifying toolpaths, Has a simple and intuitive user interface, and it shines with pros like Powerful CAD/CAM features for a low price, Easy to use even for beginners, Good support for common 3D file formats, Flexible licensing options.

Feature	Edgecam	DeskProto
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Development	Development

Product Overview

Edgecam

Description: Edgecam is CAD/CAM software designed for CNC machining applications. It allows users to import and prepare CAD models, program toolpaths for milling, turning, wire EDM, and other CNC operations, accurately simulate machining, and post NC code to machine tools.

DeskProto

Description: DeskProto is CAD/CAM software for machining free-form surfaces on CNC milling machines. It allows importing various 3D file formats, simulating and optimizing the toolpaths for 3-axis and 5-axis CNC milling machines, and outputting G-code.

Key Features Comparison

Edgecam Features

• CAD file import and model preparation
• Toolpath programming for milling, turning, wire EDM, etc.
• Accurate machining simulation
• Post-processing of G-code

DeskProto Features

• Imports various 3D file formats like STL, OBJ, 3DS, VRML, STEP, IGES, etc.
• Supports 3-axis and 5-axis CNC milling
• Generates optimized toolpaths for roughing and finishing operations
• Simulates toolpaths to detect collisions and other issues
• Supports various post-processors for outputting G-code
• Includes a customizable CAM editor for modifying toolpaths
• Has a simple and intuitive user interface

Pros & Cons Analysis

Edgecam

Pros

• Powerful toolpath programming capabilities
• Supports many machine tool types and operations
• Integrates CAD and CAM in one package
• Helpful simulation features

Cons

• Steep learning curve
• Expensive compared to other CAM options
• Limited support for some newer machine tools and operations

DeskProto

Pros

• Powerful CAD/CAM features for a low price
• Easy to use even for beginners
• Good support for common 3D file formats
• Flexible licensing options

Cons

• Limited simulation capabilities compared to high-end CAM software
• Less customizable than open-source CAM solutions
• Not as widely used as some alternatives

Pricing Comparison

Edgecam

• Subscription-Based
• Custom Pricing

DeskProto

• One-time Purchase
• Subscription-Based