Haproxy vs Nginx Proxy Manager

Struggling to choose between Haproxy and Nginx Proxy Manager? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Haproxy is a Network & Admin solution with tags like load-balancer, proxy-server, high-availability, web-server.

It boasts features such as Load balancing, Proxying, Health checking, SSL offloading, Caching, Compression, Rate limiting, Connection limiting, Queueing, Retries and timeouts, Access control lists, Logging and monitoring and pros including Open source and free, High performance, High availability, Wide protocol support, Feature rich, Active community.

On the other hand, Nginx Proxy Manager is a Network & Admin product tagged with reverse-proxy, nginx, web-interface, ssl, access-control.

Its standout features include Web-based interface for managing Nginx reverse proxy hosting, Setup proxy hosts with custom domain names, Manage SSL certificates, Access control for proxied apps/services, Load balancing for proxied apps, Customizable access rules per host, Customizable Nginx config per host, Monitoring and metrics, and it shines with pros like Easy to use graphical interface, No need to manually edit Nginx configs, Centralized management of multiple proxy hosts, Automated SSL certificate issuance and renewal, Fine-grained access control rules, Load balancing built-in, Open source and self-hosted.

Feature	Haproxy	Nginx Proxy Manager
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Network & Admin	Network & Admin

Product Overview

Haproxy

Description: HAProxy is a free, open source software that provides a high availability load balancer and proxy server. It is commonly used to improve the performance and reliability of web servers by distributing incoming requests across multiple servers.

Nginx Proxy Manager

Description: Nginx Proxy Manager is an open source web interface that makes it easy to configure and manage Nginx reverse proxy hosting. It allows you to easily set up proxy hosting, SSL certificates, and access control for your web applications and services.

Key Features Comparison

Haproxy Features

• Load balancing
• Proxying
• Health checking
• SSL offloading
• Caching
• Compression
• Rate limiting
• Connection limiting
• Queueing
• Retries and timeouts
• Access control lists
• Logging and monitoring

Nginx Proxy Manager Features

• Web-based interface for managing Nginx reverse proxy hosting
• Setup proxy hosts with custom domain names
• Manage SSL certificates
• Access control for proxied apps/services
• Load balancing for proxied apps
• Customizable access rules per host
• Customizable Nginx config per host
• Monitoring and metrics

Pros & Cons Analysis

Haproxy

Pros

• Open source and free
• High performance
• High availability
• Wide protocol support
• Feature rich
• Active community

Cons

• Steep learning curve
• Manual configuration
• Limited GUI options
• No native clustering
• Limited DDoS protection

Nginx Proxy Manager

Pros

• Easy to use graphical interface
• No need to manually edit Nginx configs
• Centralized management of multiple proxy hosts
• Automated SSL certificate issuance and renewal
• Fine-grained access control rules
• Load balancing built-in
• Open source and self-hosted

Cons

• Complex Nginx configuration not exposed
• Limited to reverse proxy use cases
• Requires separate database for storage
• Not as flexible as direct Nginx configuration
• Additional attack surface vs standalone Nginx

Pricing Comparison

Haproxy

• Open Source

Nginx Proxy Manager

• Open Source