simavr vs PICsim

Struggling to choose between simavr and PICsim? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

simavr is a Development solution with tags like simulator, avr, microcontroller, emulator, testing, firmware.

It boasts features such as Simulates popular AVR microcontrollers like ATmega128, Allows testing and debugging firmware without hardware, Supports breakpoints, watches and other debugging features, Has a GUI for inspecting registers, memory and peripherals, Can integrate with GDB for more advanced debugging, Runs on Linux, Windows and macOS and pros including Saves money by eliminating need for hardware for testing, Allows testing early in development before hardware is available, Faster testing iterations without programming physical chips, Allows testing edge cases and failure modes easily, Integrates with IDEs and GDB for familiar workflow.

On the other hand, PICsim is a Development product tagged with circuit-simulation, pic-programming, embedded-systems.

Its standout features include Circuit simulator for PIC microcontrollers, Supports various PIC models like PIC16F84A, PIC16F628A, PIC16F877A, PIC16F887, PIC18F452, etc., Allows testing PIC code on a virtual chip, Provides GUI workspace for circuit design, Includes debugging tools like breakpoints, variable watches, etc., Open-source and cross-platform (Windows, Linux, Mac), and it shines with pros like Free and open source, No need for physical PIC and hardware to test code, Fast prototyping and debugging, Supports many common PIC models, Active community support.

Feature	simavr	PICsim
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Development	Development

Product Overview

simavr

Description: simavr is an open-source AVR simulator for Linux/Windows/macOS. It can emulate popular AVR microcontrollers like ATmega128, simulating the behavior of the microcontroller so developers can test firmware without hardware.

PICsim

Description: PICsim is an open-source circuit simulator and microcontroller emulator that allows users to test and debug PIC microcontroller code on their computer. It provides a GUI workspace for designing circuits and writing/uploading code to a virtual PIC chip.

Key Features Comparison

simavr Features

• Simulates popular AVR microcontrollers like ATmega128
• Allows testing and debugging firmware without hardware
• Supports breakpoints, watches and other debugging features
• Has a GUI for inspecting registers, memory and peripherals
• Can integrate with GDB for more advanced debugging
• Runs on Linux, Windows and macOS

PICsim Features

• Circuit simulator for PIC microcontrollers
• Supports various PIC models like PIC16F84A, PIC16F628A, PIC16F877A, PIC16F887, PIC18F452, etc.
• Allows testing PIC code on a virtual chip
• Provides GUI workspace for circuit design
• Includes debugging tools like breakpoints, variable watches, etc.
• Open-source and cross-platform (Windows, Linux, Mac)

Pros & Cons Analysis

simavr

Pros

• Saves money by eliminating need for hardware for testing
• Allows testing early in development before hardware is available
• Faster testing iterations without programming physical chips
• Allows testing edge cases and failure modes easily
• Integrates with IDEs and GDB for familiar workflow

Cons

• Does not perfectly model real device behavior in all cases
• Timing may differ slightly from real hardware
• Limited to simulating AVR microcontrollers only
• Requires learning another tool besides real hardware

PICsim

Pros

• Free and open source
• No need for physical PIC and hardware to test code
• Fast prototyping and debugging
• Supports many common PIC models
• Active community support

Cons

• Limited to PIC microcontrollers only
• Not all PIC models supported
• Lacks some advanced debugging features
• GUI could be more intuitive
• Simulated environment, not 100% accurate like real hardware

Pricing Comparison

simavr

• Open Source

PICsim

• Open Source