Xbox Game Bar vs Elgato Game Capture

Struggling to choose between Xbox Game Bar and Elgato Game Capture? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Xbox Game Bar is a Gaming Software solution with tags like game-streaming, game-recording, game-broadcasting, windows.

It boasts features such as Screen recording, Screenshot capture, Audio controls, Widgets for CPU/GPU monitoring, Chat and text controls, Streaming controls and pros including Built into Windows 10 and 11, Easy to use, Free, Good basic streaming features.

On the other hand, Elgato Game Capture is a Gaming Software product tagged with video-capture, game-recording, live-streaming, console-gaming, pc-gaming.

Its standout features include Capture gameplay footage from consoles or PC, Livestream or record gameplay, Edit and upload captured videos, Add overlays, webcam footage, etc, Capture audio from mics and game audio, Flashback Recording to capture last 30 seconds, Stream Command to add alerts/effects, Built-in live commentary features, Chroma Key to remove backgrounds, Multi-track audio editing, Export to various formats, and it shines with pros like Easy to set up and use, Great quality video capture, Lots of editing features, Compatible with many games/consoles/PCs, Reliable capturing and streaming, Affordable price.

Feature	Xbox Game Bar	Elgato Game Capture
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Gaming Software	Gaming Software

Product Overview

Xbox Game Bar

Description: Xbox Game Bar is a built-in app for Windows 10 and Windows 11 for taking screenshots, recording gameplay videos, starting party chats, and broadcasting your stream to Mixer or Twitch from your PC. It provides gamers with basic streaming and social functions without needing to download or install additional software.

Elgato Game Capture

Description: Elgato Game Capture is a video capturing device and software that allows users to record or stream gameplay footage from consoles or PCs. It connects to a computer via USB and captures video and audio directly from the console or PC, then transfers it to the computer for livestreaming, editing, or uploading.

Key Features Comparison

Xbox Game Bar Features

• Screen recording
• Screenshot capture
• Audio controls
• Widgets for CPU/GPU monitoring
• Chat and text controls
• Streaming controls

Elgato Game Capture Features

• Capture gameplay footage from consoles or PC
• Livestream or record gameplay
• Edit and upload captured videos
• Add overlays, webcam footage, etc
• Capture audio from mics and game audio
• Flashback Recording to capture last 30 seconds
• Stream Command to add alerts/effects
• Built-in live commentary features
• Chroma Key to remove backgrounds
• Multi-track audio editing
• Export to various formats

Pros & Cons Analysis

Xbox Game Bar

Pros

• Built into Windows 10 and 11
• Easy to use
• Free
• Good basic streaming features

Cons

• Limited compared to dedicated streaming software
• Can impact game performance
• Limited customization options

Elgato Game Capture

Pros

• Easy to set up and use
• Great quality video capture
• Lots of editing features
• Compatible with many games/consoles/PCs
• Reliable capturing and streaming
• Affordable price

Cons

• Can be resource intensive
• Limited flashback recording time
• May require extra purchase for HDCP support
• Fewer features than full video editing suites
• Can take time to optimize settings
• May need separate mic for best audio quality

Pricing Comparison

Xbox Game Bar

• Free

Elgato Game Capture

• One-time Purchase