API Umbrella vs 3Scale

Struggling to choose between API Umbrella and 3Scale? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

API Umbrella is a Development solution with tags like api, proxy, analytics, access-control, rate-limiting.

It boasts features such as Rate limiting to prevent API abuse, Analytics to track API usage and performance, Access control to manage which APIs users can access, Developer portal for API documentation and onboarding, Caching for improved performance, Load balancing across multiple API servers, SSL termination at the edge, Granular access rules per API, Customizable admin and developer portals and pros including Open source and free to use, Simple and quick to setup compared to other API management platforms, Good for basic API management needs, Customizable via extensions, Active open source community.

On the other hand, 3Scale is a Online Services product tagged with api, analytics, access-control, rate-limiting, developer-portals, monetization.

Its standout features include API analytics, Access control, Rate limiting, Developer portals, Monetization tools, and it shines with pros like Easy to set up and manage APIs, Flexible pricing and packaging options, Good analytics and reporting, Self-service developer portal, Works well for public, private or partner APIs.

To help you make an informed decision, we've compiled a comprehensive comparison of these two products, delving into their features, pros, cons, pricing, and more. Get ready to explore the nuances that set them apart and determine which one is the perfect fit for your requirements.

API Umbrella

API Umbrella

API Umbrella is an open source API management platform that provides rate limiting, analytics, access control, and developer portals for APIs. It acts as a proxy layer in front of APIs to provide control over API traffic.

Categories:
Development Api Management
api proxy analytics access-control rate-limiting

API Umbrella Features

  1. Rate limiting to prevent API abuse
  2. Analytics to track API usage and performance
  3. Access control to manage which APIs users can access
  4. Developer portal for API documentation and onboarding
  5. Caching for improved performance
  6. Load balancing across multiple API servers
  7. SSL termination at the edge
  8. Granular access rules per API
  9. Customizable admin and developer portals

Pricing

  • Open Source
  • Custom Pricing

Pros

Open source and free to use

Simple and quick to setup compared to other API management platforms

Good for basic API management needs

Customizable via extensions

Active open source community

Cons

Lacks some advanced features of commercial platforms

Admin UI not as polished as some alternatives

Can be complex to customize and extend

Limited native support for API transformations

Not ideal for large enterprise deployments

3Scale

3Scale

3Scale is an API management platform that allows API providers to manage and scale their APIs. Key features include API analytics, access control, rate limiting, developer portals, and monetization tools.

Categories:
Online Services Api Management
api analytics access-control rate-limiting developer-portals monetization

3Scale Features

  1. API analytics
  2. Access control
  3. Rate limiting
  4. Developer portals
  5. Monetization tools

Pricing

  • Freemium
  • Subscription-Based

Pros

Easy to set up and manage APIs

Flexible pricing and packaging options

Good analytics and reporting

Self-service developer portal

Works well for public, private or partner APIs

Cons

Can be complex for non-technical users

Advanced features require coding

Limited native integrations with API gateways

Developer portal customization requires work