Cisco Umbrella vs DNS Redirector

Struggling to choose between Cisco Umbrella and DNS Redirector? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Cisco Umbrella is a Security & Privacy solution with tags like cloud-security, dns-filtering, threat-protection, web-filtering, endpoint-protection.

It boasts features such as Secure Internet Gateway, DNS-layer security, Threat Intelligence, Roaming Clients, Reporting and Analytics, Integrated Threat Protection and pros including Provides comprehensive internet security, Easy to deploy and manage, Scalable and cloud-based, Integrates with other Cisco security solutions, Offers real-time threat intelligence.

On the other hand, DNS Redirector is a Network & Admin product tagged with dns, redirect, ad-blocking, web-development.

Its standout features include Redirects DNS queries to different IP addresses, Works as local DNS server/proxy, Supports wildcards and regex for flexible redirect rules, Open source and free to use, and it shines with pros like Blocks ads and malware sites, Useful for web development and testing environments, Lightweight and easy to setup, Actively developed and maintained.

Feature	Cisco Umbrella	DNS Redirector
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Security & Privacy	Network & Admin

Product Overview

Cisco Umbrella

Description: Cisco Umbrella is a cloud security platform that provides the first line of defense against threats on the internet. It blocks requests to malicious domains, IPs, URLs and files before a connection is established or a file is downloaded.

DNS Redirector

Description: DNS Redirector is a free, open-source software that allows you to redirect DNS queries. It works by intercepting DNS requests and responding with customized IP addresses instead of the actual ones. Useful for blocking ads, malware sites, and implementing local web development environments.

Key Features Comparison

Cisco Umbrella Features

• Secure Internet Gateway
• DNS-layer security
• Threat Intelligence
• Roaming Clients
• Reporting and Analytics
• Integrated Threat Protection

DNS Redirector Features

• Redirects DNS queries to different IP addresses
• Works as local DNS server/proxy
• Supports wildcards and regex for flexible redirect rules
• Open source and free to use

Pros & Cons Analysis

Cisco Umbrella

Pros

• Provides comprehensive internet security
• Easy to deploy and manage
• Scalable and cloud-based
• Integrates with other Cisco security solutions
• Offers real-time threat intelligence

Cons

• Can be more expensive than some alternative solutions
• May require additional licenses for advanced features
• Some users have reported performance issues

DNS Redirector

Pros

• Blocks ads and malware sites
• Useful for web development and testing environments
• Lightweight and easy to setup
• Actively developed and maintained

Cons

• Requires some technical knowledge to configure
• Potential for misconfiguration that breaks sites
• Extra network hop may increase latency
• Limited to DNS-based blocking only

Pricing Comparison

Cisco Umbrella

• Subscription-Based

DNS Redirector

• Open Source
• Free