Google Cloud Storage Coldline vs Amazon S3 Glacier

Struggling to choose between Google Cloud Storage Coldline and Amazon S3 Glacier? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Google Cloud Storage Coldline is a Online Services solution with tags like cold-storage, backups, archives, disaster-recovery.

It boasts features such as Low-cost cloud storage for infrequently accessed data, High durability with geo-redundancy, Minimum 90 day storage duration, Automatic migration of data to Coldline after 30 days, Per-GB pricing for storage and access and pros including Cost-effective for long-term data archiving, Durable backup and disaster recovery option, Easy to set data lifecycle policies, Seamless integration with other GCP services.

On the other hand, Amazon S3 Glacier is a Online Services product tagged with archiving, backup, storage.

Its standout features include Archival storage for long-term data retention, Extremely low cost - as low as $0.004 per GB per month, Data is stored across multiple facilities and multiple devices, Data is encrypted at rest and in transit, Lifecycle policies to transition data to lower cost tiers, Data retrieval options from expedited to bulk retrievals, Integrates with other AWS services like S3, CloudTrail, etc., and it shines with pros like Very low cost for infrequently accessed data, Highly durable and secure storage, Easy to scale capacity, Automated data lifecycle management, Fast retrieval options available if needed.

Feature	Google Cloud Storage Coldline	Amazon S3 Glacier
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Online Services	Online Services

Product Overview

Google Cloud Storage Coldline

Description: Google Cloud Storage Coldline is an affordable, long-term cloud storage service for data that is infrequently accessed and stored for at least 90 days. It provides low cost, high durability storage for backups, archives, and disaster recovery.

Amazon S3 Glacier

Description: Amazon S3 Glacier is a secure, durable, and extremely low-cost cloud storage service for data archiving and long-term backup. It allows customers to store large amounts of data for as little as $0.004 per gigabyte per month.

Key Features Comparison

Google Cloud Storage Coldline Features

• Low-cost cloud storage for infrequently accessed data
• High durability with geo-redundancy
• Minimum 90 day storage duration
• Automatic migration of data to Coldline after 30 days
• Per-GB pricing for storage and access

Amazon S3 Glacier Features

• Archival storage for long-term data retention
• Extremely low cost - as low as $0.004 per GB per month
• Data is stored across multiple facilities and multiple devices
• Data is encrypted at rest and in transit
• Lifecycle policies to transition data to lower cost tiers
• Data retrieval options from expedited to bulk retrievals
• Integrates with other AWS services like S3, CloudTrail, etc.

Pros & Cons Analysis

Google Cloud Storage Coldline

Pros

• Cost-effective for long-term data archiving
• Durable backup and disaster recovery option
• Easy to set data lifecycle policies
• Seamless integration with other GCP services

Cons

• Higher per-operation costs than Standard or Nearline storage
• Minimum 90 day storage period
• Higher latency for data access compared to Standard or Nearline storage
• No deletion before 90 days without fees

Amazon S3 Glacier

Pros

• Very low cost for infrequently accessed data
• Highly durable and secure storage
• Easy to scale capacity
• Automated data lifecycle management
• Fast retrieval options available if needed

Cons

• Retrieval latency is high - data is offline
• Only accessible via API/SDK - no console
• No in-place editing of objects - must be rewritten
• No object versioning like S3
• No object metadata search capability

Pricing Comparison

Google Cloud Storage Coldline

• Pay-As-You-Go

Amazon S3 Glacier

• Pay-As-You-Go