Graphite (SIL) vs GNU gettext

Struggling to choose between Graphite (SIL) and GNU gettext? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Graphite (SIL) is a Education & Reference solution with tags like orthography, language-development, sil, nonlatin-scripts.

It boasts features such as Orthography design, Font development, Keyboard layout design, Dictionary development, Reading material development and pros including Free and open source, User-friendly interface, Supports minority languages, Allows collaboration.

On the other hand, GNU gettext is a Development product tagged with translation, localization, internationalization, i18n.

Its standout features include Translation Memory - Stores translations for reuse, Plural Forms - Supports plural forms in translations, PO Files - Stores translations in portable object (PO) text files, GNU Gettext Utilities - Command line tools like msgfmt, msgmerge, xgettext, Programming APIs - APIs for multiple programming languages like C, Python, PHP, Perl, Ruby, etc, Charset Conversion - Automatically converts between character sets, Context Support - Supports pgettext for context-aware translations, and it shines with pros like Widely used and well supported, Integrates well with common programming languages, Helps produce professional quality translations, Reduces localization costs by reusing translations, Open source with active development community.

Feature	Graphite (SIL)	GNU gettext
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Education & Reference	Development

Product Overview

Graphite (SIL)

Description: Graphite is a learner-friendly software tool, created by SIL international, that enables language communities to adapt Latin script to new languages. It allows users to easily design, publish and share practical orthographies.

GNU gettext

Description: GNU gettext is a software translation tool that allows programmers to write applications with interfaces that can be translated into multiple languages. It provides localization support for software.

Key Features Comparison

Graphite (SIL) Features

• Orthography design
• Font development
• Keyboard layout design
• Dictionary development
• Reading material development

GNU gettext Features

• Translation Memory - Stores translations for reuse
• Plural Forms - Supports plural forms in translations
• PO Files - Stores translations in portable object (PO) text files
• GNU Gettext Utilities - Command line tools like msgfmt, msgmerge, xgettext
• Programming APIs - APIs for multiple programming languages like C, Python, PHP, Perl, Ruby, etc
• Charset Conversion - Automatically converts between character sets
• Context Support - Supports pgettext for context-aware translations

Pros & Cons Analysis

Graphite (SIL)

Pros

• Free and open source
• User-friendly interface
• Supports minority languages
• Allows collaboration

Cons

• Limited language support
• Steep learning curve
• Requires technical knowledge

GNU gettext

Pros

• Widely used and well supported
• Integrates well with common programming languages
• Helps produce professional quality translations
• Reduces localization costs by reusing translations
• Open source with active development community

Cons

• Can have a steep learning curve
• Formatting codes in PO files can be confusing
• Not as user friendly as some paid alternatives
• Limited WYSIWYG editor options
• Requires programming knowledge to fully utilize

Pricing Comparison

Graphite (SIL)

• Free
• Open Source

GNU gettext

• Open Source