Keywhiz vs AWS Secrets Manager

Struggling to choose between Keywhiz and AWS Secrets Manager? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Keywhiz is a Security & Privacy solution with tags like secrets-management, authentication-keys, passwords, access-control.

It boasts features such as Secure storage and controlled access to secrets, Role-based access control, Audit logging, Automated secret rotation, Integrations with applications and infrastructure and pros including Improves security by centralizing secret management, Simplifies secret distribution across infrastructure, Reduces risk of compromised credentials, Increases visibility into access of sensitive data.

On the other hand, AWS Secrets Manager is a Security & Privacy product tagged with aws, secrets, credentials, rotation.

Its standout features include Store and manage secrets centrally, Rotate secrets automatically without disruption, Integrate with AWS services and RDS databases, Fine-grained access controls, Encryption at rest and in transit, Audit secret usage, and it shines with pros like Improves security by centralizing secret storage, Simplifies secret management through automation, Reduces risk of compromised credentials, Integrates seamlessly with AWS services, Serverless, easy to setup and use.

Feature	Keywhiz	AWS Secrets Manager
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Security & Privacy	Security & Privacy

Product Overview

Keywhiz

Description: Keywhiz is an open-source software system that helps manage and distribute secrets such as passwords and authentication keys. It provides secure storage and controlled access based on role-based permissions.

AWS Secrets Manager

Description: AWS Secrets Manager is a service that enables you to store, manage, and retrieve credentials for databases, services, and applications securely. It integrates with AWS services and enables you to rotate credentials automatically without disruption.

Key Features Comparison

Keywhiz Features

• Secure storage and controlled access to secrets
• Role-based access control
• Audit logging
• Automated secret rotation
• Integrations with applications and infrastructure

AWS Secrets Manager Features

• Store and manage secrets centrally
• Rotate secrets automatically without disruption
• Integrate with AWS services and RDS databases
• Fine-grained access controls
• Encryption at rest and in transit
• Audit secret usage

Pros & Cons Analysis

Keywhiz

Pros

• Improves security by centralizing secret management
• Simplifies secret distribution across infrastructure
• Reduces risk of compromised credentials
• Increases visibility into access of sensitive data

Cons

• Additional system to deploy and manage
• Requires changing application configuration
• Limited native integrations compared to commercial solutions

AWS Secrets Manager

Pros

• Improves security by centralizing secret storage
• Simplifies secret management through automation
• Reduces risk of compromised credentials
• Integrates seamlessly with AWS services
• Serverless, easy to setup and use

Cons

• Additional service to manage and pay for
• Limited visibility into secrets access
• Rotating secrets can cause downtime if not tested
• Only available in some AWS regions

Pricing Comparison

Keywhiz

• Open Source

AWS Secrets Manager

• Pay-As-You-Go