Magic Wormhole vs OnionShare

Struggling to choose between Magic Wormhole and OnionShare? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Magic Wormhole is a File Sharing solution with tags like file-transfer, p2p, open-source.

It boasts features such as Peer-to-peer file transfer, Uses a simple 9-character passphrase for authentication, Transfers files by relaying encrypted data through a relay server, Open source and available on GitHub, Available as a Python library and command line tool, Cross-platform - works on Linux, macOS, Windows, Encrypted end-to-end so files are secure in transit, Lightweight and easy to use and pros including Free and open source, Simple to use with minimal setup, Secure encryption protects files in transit, Cross-platform compatibility, Actively maintained and updated.

On the other hand, OnionShare is a Security & Privacy product tagged with file-sharing, anonymous, tor, encryption.

Its standout features include Allows anonymous file sharing over Tor network, Encrypts files before uploading, Creates one-time website to share files, Works on Windows, Mac and Linux, Open source and free, and it shines with pros like Highly secure and private, Easy to use interface, Does not require recipient to install any software, Allows sharing large files anonymously, Completely free with no limits.

Feature	Magic Wormhole	OnionShare
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	File Sharing	Security & Privacy

Product Overview

Magic Wormhole

Description: Magic Wormhole is a free and open source peer-to-peer file transfer and communication tool. It allows users to securely transfer files and data between computers by using a randomly generated 9-character passphrase for authentication.

OnionShare

Description: OnionShare is an open source tool that allows you to securely and anonymously share files of any size. It works by hosting a one-time website accessible over the Tor network, allowing recipients to download files without revealing the sender's identity.

Key Features Comparison

Magic Wormhole Features

• Peer-to-peer file transfer
• Uses a simple 9-character passphrase for authentication
• Transfers files by relaying encrypted data through a relay server
• Open source and available on GitHub
• Available as a Python library and command line tool
• Cross-platform - works on Linux, macOS, Windows
• Encrypted end-to-end so files are secure in transit
• Lightweight and easy to use

OnionShare Features

• Allows anonymous file sharing over Tor network
• Encrypts files before uploading
• Creates one-time website to share files
• Works on Windows, Mac and Linux
• Open source and free

Pros & Cons Analysis

Magic Wormhole

Pros

• Free and open source
• Simple to use with minimal setup
• Secure encryption protects files in transit
• Cross-platform compatibility
• Actively maintained and updated

Cons

• Relies on third-party relay servers
• Limited documentation and support resources
• Not suitable for very large file transfers
• Command line interface not user-friendly for non-technical users

OnionShare

Pros

• Highly secure and private
• Easy to use interface
• Does not require recipient to install any software
• Allows sharing large files anonymously
• Completely free with no limits

Cons

• Requires Tor browser
• Slow transfer speeds
• No way to verify recipient got the file
• Requires some technical knowledge to use
• Limited to one-time website for each share

Pricing Comparison

Magic Wormhole

• Open Source

OnionShare

• Open Source
• Free