McCAD 3SPICE vs Ngspice

Struggling to choose between McCAD 3SPICE and Ngspice? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

McCAD 3SPICE is a Development solution with tags like circuit-simulation, pcb-design, spice.

It boasts features such as SPICE simulation engine, Analog, digital and mixed-mode circuit simulation, Intuitive schematic capture, PCB layout and autorouting, 3D visualization, Model library with 7000+ components, Waveform viewer, Virtual instruments, Import/export netlists and pros including Powerful simulation capabilities, Good for learning and education, Affordable pricing, Easy to use interface, Integrated schematic and PCB design.

On the other hand, Ngspice is a Development product tagged with electronics, semiconductors, circuit-simulation, spice-models, analog-circuits, digital-circuits, mixedsignal-circuits.

Its standout features include SPICE circuit simulator, Supports digital, analog and mixed-mode circuits, Has an extensive model library, Supports PSpice compatible models, Has a graphical waveform viewer, Can generate netlists from schematics, Has Monte Carlo and worst-case analysis, Can do DC, AC, Transient and Fourier analysis, and it shines with pros like Free and open source, Powerful simulation capabilities, Large model library, Compatible with many SPICE models, Good for learning circuit simulation.

To help you make an informed decision, we've compiled a comprehensive comparison of these two products, delving into their features, pros, cons, pricing, and more. Get ready to explore the nuances that set them apart and determine which one is the perfect fit for your requirements.

McCAD 3SPICE

McCAD 3SPICE

McCAD 3SPICE is an electronic circuit simulation and PCB design software tool used for analog, digital and mixed circuit simulations. It allows engineers to test circuit designs without building prototypes.

Categories:
circuit-simulation pcb-design spice

McCAD 3SPICE Features

  1. SPICE simulation engine
  2. Analog, digital and mixed-mode circuit simulation
  3. Intuitive schematic capture
  4. PCB layout and autorouting
  5. 3D visualization
  6. Model library with 7000+ components
  7. Waveform viewer
  8. Virtual instruments
  9. Import/export netlists

Pricing

  • Free limited version
  • One-time purchase
  • Subscription-based

Pros

Powerful simulation capabilities

Good for learning and education

Affordable pricing

Easy to use interface

Integrated schematic and PCB design

Cons

Limited component library compared to premium tools

No collaborative features

Lacks some advanced analysis features

Technical support could be better


Ngspice

Ngspice

Ngspice is an open-source circuit simulator for electronics and semiconductors. It allows analyzing, modeling, and testing analog, digital and mixed-signal circuits with over 500 spice models of MOSFETs, BJTs, diodes, transformers, etc.

Categories:
electronics semiconductors circuit-simulation spice-models analog-circuits digital-circuits mixedsignal-circuits

Ngspice Features

  1. SPICE circuit simulator
  2. Supports digital, analog and mixed-mode circuits
  3. Has an extensive model library
  4. Supports PSpice compatible models
  5. Has a graphical waveform viewer
  6. Can generate netlists from schematics
  7. Has Monte Carlo and worst-case analysis
  8. Can do DC, AC, Transient and Fourier analysis

Pricing

  • Open Source

Pros

Free and open source

Powerful simulation capabilities

Large model library

Compatible with many SPICE models

Good for learning circuit simulation

Cons

Steep learning curve

Limited documentation and support

No integrated schematic editor

User interface is not very intuitive