OWASP Dependency-Track vs Black Duck Software

Struggling to choose between OWASP Dependency-Track and Black Duck Software? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

OWASP Dependency-Track is a Security & Privacy solution with tags like opensource, software-composition-analysis, supply-chain, dependency-management, license-compliance.

It boasts features such as Dependency analysis, Vulnerability analysis, License analysis, Bill of materials (BOM) management, Software component intelligence, Web UI and REST API, Integrations with build tools and repositories and pros including Free and open source, Helps identify and reduce risk from open source usage, Provides visibility into software supply chain, Customizable rules and policies, Can integrate with CI/CD pipelines.

On the other hand, Black Duck Software is a Security & Privacy product tagged with open-source, security, compliance, code-quality.

Its standout features include Automated detection of open source components, Vulnerability monitoring, License compliance management, Code quality analysis, Application security testing, Container image scanning, and it shines with pros like Comprehensive open source management, Integration with CI/CD pipelines, Large knowledgebase of open source components, Policy enforcement and governance, Customizable dashboards and reporting.

Feature	OWASP Dependency-Track	Black Duck Software
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Security & Privacy	Security & Privacy

Product Overview

OWASP Dependency-Track

Description: OWASP Dependency-Track is an open source software composition analysis tool that allows organizations to identify and reduce risk from the use of third-party and open source components. It scans project dependencies and generates reports on vulnerabilities, licenses, and other metadata to support policy enforcement and provide visibility into software supply chain risks.

Black Duck Software

Description: Black Duck Software offers solutions for managing open source security, compliance, and code quality across an organization's applications and containers. Its flagship products include Synopsys Black Duck for automated detection and remediation of open source vulnerabilities.

Key Features Comparison

OWASP Dependency-Track Features

• Dependency analysis
• Vulnerability analysis
• License analysis
• Bill of materials (BOM) management
• Software component intelligence
• Web UI and REST API
• Integrations with build tools and repositories

Black Duck Software Features

• Automated detection of open source components
• Vulnerability monitoring
• License compliance management
• Code quality analysis
• Application security testing
• Container image scanning

Pros & Cons Analysis

OWASP Dependency-Track

Pros

• Free and open source
• Helps identify and reduce risk from open source usage
• Provides visibility into software supply chain
• Customizable rules and policies
• Can integrate with CI/CD pipelines

Cons

• Requires some effort to setup and configure
• Limited scalability compared to commercial SCA tools
• Lacks some advanced features like auto-remediation

Black Duck Software

Pros

• Comprehensive open source management
• Integration with CI/CD pipelines
• Large knowledgebase of open source components
• Policy enforcement and governance
• Customizable dashboards and reporting

Cons

• Complex setup and configuration
• Steep learning curve
• Can be resource intensive to scan large codebases
• Limited support for some languages and frameworks

Pricing Comparison

OWASP Dependency-Track

• Open Source

Black Duck Software

• Subscription-Based
• Pay-As-You-Go