Skip to content

PaperDungeonMaker vs PlanarAlly

Professional comparison and analysis to help you choose the right software solution for your needs.

PaperDungeonMaker icon
PaperDungeonMaker
PlanarAlly icon
PlanarAlly

PaperDungeonMaker vs PlanarAlly: The Verdict

Last updated: May 2026 · Comparison by Sugggest Editorial Team

Feature PaperDungeonMaker PlanarAlly
Sugggest Score
Category Games Gaming Software
Pricing Free Open Source

Product Overview

PaperDungeonMaker
PaperDungeonMaker

Description: PaperDungeonMaker is a free software that lets you easily design and print custom paper miniatures and tile-based dungeon maps for tabletop RPGs. It has a simple drag and drop interface to place walls, doors, traps and props to build intricate dungeons.

Type: software

Pricing: Free

PlanarAlly
PlanarAlly

Description: PlanarAlly is a free, open source virtual tabletop software for tabletop roleplaying games like Dungeons & Dragons. It allows game masters to create maps, tokens, dice rollers, and more to enhance the gameplay experience.

Type: software

Pricing: Open Source

Key Features Comparison

PaperDungeonMaker
PaperDungeonMaker Features
  • Drag and drop interface for building dungeons
  • Customizable tiles, walls, doors, traps, props
  • Generate printable PDFs of dungeon maps
  • Create custom paper miniatures
  • Share and export creations
  • Online prop library
PlanarAlly
PlanarAlly Features
  • Create interactive maps with fog of war
  • Import custom artwork and tokens
  • Built-in dice roller and initiative tracker
  • Collaborative editing for GMs and players
  • Support for multiple game systems like D&D 5e
  • Customizable character sheets and macros
  • Chat and video/voice conferencing
  • Cross-platform - runs in browser, Windows, Mac, Linux

Pros & Cons Analysis

PaperDungeonMaker
PaperDungeonMaker
Pros
  • Free and easy to use
  • Great for tabletop RPG players
  • Allows customization and creativity
  • Saves time compared to hand-drawing maps
  • Exports high quality printable PDFs
Cons
  • Limited tilesets and prop library
  • No support for 3D or animated maps
  • Requires printing resources to get full use
  • May take time to learn for new users
PlanarAlly
PlanarAlly
Pros
  • Free and open source
  • Very customizable and extensible
  • Active development and community support
  • Runs locally so no internet required for gameplay
  • More lightweight than some alternatives
Cons
  • Steep learning curve
  • Limited mobile support
  • Fewer out-of-the-box assets than some competitors
  • Voice/video can be unstable

Pricing Comparison

PaperDungeonMaker
PaperDungeonMaker
  • Free
PlanarAlly
PlanarAlly
  • Open Source

Ready to Make Your Decision?

Explore more software comparisons and find the perfect solution for your needs