RANCID vs Network Configuration Manager

Struggling to choose between RANCID and Network Configuration Manager? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

RANCID is a Network & Admin solution with tags like router-configuration, switch-configuration, network-monitoring, open-source.

It boasts features such as Automated configuration tracking for routers and switches, Detects and archives changes to device configurations, Allows network administrators to track and roll back changes, Supports a wide range of network devices and protocols, Integrates with version control systems like CVS, Subversion, and Git, Provides command-line and web-based interfaces for configuration management and pros including Open-source and free to use, Provides comprehensive configuration management for network devices, Supports a wide range of network equipment from various vendors, Allows for easy rollback of unwanted configuration changes, Integrates with popular version control systems.

On the other hand, Network Configuration Manager is a Network & Admin product tagged with networking, configuration, management, backups, version-control, change-tracking, policy-compliance, bulk-edits.

Its standout features include Centralized management of network device configurations, Automated configuration backups and version control, Bulk configuration changes across multiple devices, Change tracking and audit logs, Policy compliance checking, Template-based configuration management, Role-based access control, and it shines with pros like Improves efficiency and reduces errors, Enables standardization and policy enforcement, Simplifies change management, Enhances network security and compliance.

Feature	RANCID	Network Configuration Manager
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Network & Admin	Network & Admin

Product Overview

RANCID

Description: RANCID is an open-source network monitoring software that keeps track of router and switch configurations. It detects changes to configurations by regularly checking devices and archiving new revisions. This allows network administrators to track changes and roll back unwanted modifications.

Network Configuration Manager

Description: Network Configuration Manager is a software tool that allows network administrators to centrally manage the configurations of networking devices like routers, switches, and firewalls. It provides features like automated configuration backups, version control, change tracking, policy compliance checking, and bulk edits.

Key Features Comparison

RANCID Features

• Automated configuration tracking for routers and switches
• Detects and archives changes to device configurations
• Allows network administrators to track and roll back changes
• Supports a wide range of network devices and protocols
• Integrates with version control systems like CVS, Subversion, and Git
• Provides command-line and web-based interfaces for configuration management

Network Configuration Manager Features

• Centralized management of network device configurations
• Automated configuration backups and version control
• Bulk configuration changes across multiple devices
• Change tracking and audit logs
• Policy compliance checking
• Template-based configuration management
• Role-based access control

Pros & Cons Analysis

RANCID

Pros

• Open-source and free to use
• Provides comprehensive configuration management for network devices
• Supports a wide range of network equipment from various vendors
• Allows for easy rollback of unwanted configuration changes
• Integrates with popular version control systems

Cons

• Steep learning curve for new users
• Limited support for newer network technologies and protocols
• Requires manual configuration and setup for each network device

Network Configuration Manager

Pros

• Improves efficiency and reduces errors
• Enables standardization and policy enforcement
• Simplifies change management
• Enhances network security and compliance

Cons

• Can have a steep learning curve
• Requires initial investment of time and effort
• May require specific training for staff
• Potential for configuration errors if not used properly

Pricing Comparison

RANCID

• Open Source

Network Configuration Manager

• Subscription-Based
• Pay-As-You-Go