Shinken vs Icinga

Struggling to choose between Shinken and Icinga? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Shinken is a Network & Admin solution with tags like opensource, monitoring, nagioscompatible, scalable.

It boasts features such as Distributed monitoring architecture, Horizontal scalability, Nagios configuration file compatibility, Nagios plugin compatibility, Web-based UI, REST API, Alerting and notification capabilities, Reporting and graphing, Service checks, Host checks, Dependency handling and pros including Good scalability, Large ecosystem of Nagios plugins, Open source and free, Web UI for easy management, REST API for automation, Compatible with existing Nagios configs.

On the other hand, Icinga is a Network & Admin product tagged with monitoring, alerting, reporting.

Its standout features include Real-time monitoring, Alerting and notifications, Automated service checks, Plugin architecture, Web interface, REST API, Distributed monitoring, Reporting, Visualization, Auto-discovery, Configuration management, Clustering, High availability, and it shines with pros like Open source, Flexible and extensible, Wide range of plugins, Scalable, Good community support, Integrates with other tools, Customizable dashboards, Good documentation.

To help you make an informed decision, we've compiled a comprehensive comparison of these two products, delving into their features, pros, cons, pricing, and more. Get ready to explore the nuances that set them apart and determine which one is the perfect fit for your requirements.

Shinken

Shinken

Shinken is an open-source monitoring framework that is compatible with Nagios configuration and plugins. It is designed to scale to large environments with thousands of hosts and services. Shinken leverages distributed architecture to improve performance over Nagios.

Categories:
opensource monitoring nagioscompatible scalable

Shinken Features

  1. Distributed monitoring architecture
  2. Horizontal scalability
  3. Nagios configuration file compatibility
  4. Nagios plugin compatibility
  5. Web-based UI
  6. REST API
  7. Alerting and notification capabilities
  8. Reporting and graphing
  9. Service checks
  10. Host checks
  11. Dependency handling

Pricing

  • Open Source

Pros

Good scalability

Large ecosystem of Nagios plugins

Open source and free

Web UI for easy management

REST API for automation

Compatible with existing Nagios configs

Cons

Steeper learning curve than Nagios

Additional components to install and configure

Not as widely used as Nagios

Limited official support


Icinga

Icinga

Icinga is an open source IT monitoring tool used to monitor network services, servers, applications, and business processes. It can send notifications about issues and outages, as well as generate reports on infrastructure performance.

Categories:
monitoring alerting reporting

Icinga Features

  1. Real-time monitoring
  2. Alerting and notifications
  3. Automated service checks
  4. Plugin architecture
  5. Web interface
  6. REST API
  7. Distributed monitoring
  8. Reporting
  9. Visualization
  10. Auto-discovery
  11. Configuration management
  12. Clustering
  13. High availability

Pricing

  • Open Source

Pros

Open source

Flexible and extensible

Wide range of plugins

Scalable

Good community support

Integrates with other tools

Customizable dashboards

Good documentation

Cons

Complex setup and configuration

Steep learning curve

Limited native Windows monitoring

No built-in log monitoring

Limited native cloud monitoring