WebScarab vs Charles

Struggling to choose between WebScarab and Charles? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

WebScarab is a Security & Privacy solution with tags like interception, analysis, vulnerability-testing, web-security.

It boasts features such as Intercepts HTTP and HTTPS traffic, Analyzes requests/responses for security issues, Tests for vulnerabilities like XSS, SQLi, etc, Has proxy functionality to view and modify traffic, Can manipulate requests to test apps, Passive and active scanning modes, Session tracking and analysis, Spidering to crawl web apps, Extensible via plugins and pros including Free and open source, Powerful proxy functionality, Can detect many vulnerabilities, Extensible and customizable, Actively maintained, Cross-platform.

On the other hand, Charles is a Development product tagged with proxy, http, https, monitor, reverse-proxy.

Its standout features include HTTP proxy, HTTP monitor, Reverse proxy, View HTTP/HTTPS traffic, View requests, View responses, View HTTP headers, View cookies, View caching information, and it shines with pros like Debug HTTP/HTTPS connections, Inspect traffic between machine and internet, Identify performance issues, Troubleshoot network requests.

Feature	WebScarab	Charles
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Security & Privacy	Development

Product Overview

WebScarab

Description: WebScarab is an open source web application security testing tool that allows users to intercept HTTP and HTTPS requests and responses and analyze them for security vulnerabilities. It can be used to test web apps for issues like cross-site scripting, SQL injection, and more.

Charles

Description: Charles is an HTTP proxy / HTTP monitor / Reverse Proxy that enables a developer to view all of the HTTP and SSL / HTTPS traffic between their machine and the Internet. This includes requests, responses and the HTTP headers (which contain the cookies and caching information).

Key Features Comparison

WebScarab Features

• Intercepts HTTP and HTTPS traffic
• Analyzes requests/responses for security issues
• Tests for vulnerabilities like XSS, SQLi, etc
• Has proxy functionality to view and modify traffic
• Can manipulate requests to test apps
• Passive and active scanning modes
• Session tracking and analysis
• Spidering to crawl web apps
• Extensible via plugins

Charles Features

• HTTP proxy
• HTTP monitor
• Reverse proxy
• View HTTP/HTTPS traffic
• View requests
• View responses
• View HTTP headers
• View cookies
• View caching information

Pros & Cons Analysis

WebScarab

Pros

• Free and open source
• Powerful proxy functionality
• Can detect many vulnerabilities
• Extensible and customizable
• Actively maintained
• Cross-platform

Cons

• Steep learning curve
• Setup can be complex
• Not as user-friendly as commercial tools
• Limited reporting capabilities
• Can be resource intensive

Charles

Pros

• Debug HTTP/HTTPS connections
• Inspect traffic between machine and internet
• Identify performance issues
• Troubleshoot network requests

Cons

• Steep learning curve
• Manual configuration required
• Extra overhead for all HTTP traffic
• Potential privacy concerns

Pricing Comparison

WebScarab

• Open Source

Charles

• Free
• Open Source