ZoneMinder vs Shinobi

Struggling to choose between ZoneMinder and Shinobi? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

ZoneMinder is a Security & Privacy solution with tags like video, surveillance, motion-detection, recording, notifications, open-source.

It boasts features such as Live view and playback of IP cameras, Motion detection and event notifications, Continuous, scheduled, or motion-triggered recording, Remote access via web browser or mobile app, Support for a wide variety of IP cameras, Open source and self-hosted (no vendor lock-in), Event-driven automation via hooks into other applications and pros including Free and open source, Self-hosted so you control your data, Works with many different camera models, Good community support, Highly customizable and integrates well with other tools.

On the other hand, Shinobi is a Security & Privacy product tagged with cctv, video-surveillance, monitoring, motion-detection, alerts.

Its standout features include IP camera management, Live video streaming, Motion detection, Video recording, User management, Email/SMS alerts, and it shines with pros like Open source, Flexible platform, Wide device support, Customizable, Self-hosted option.

Feature	ZoneMinder	Shinobi
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Security & Privacy	Security & Privacy

Product Overview

ZoneMinder

Description: ZoneMinder is an open source video surveillance software that allows you to monitor multiple IP cameras from a central web interface. It supports motion detection, event notifications, and recording video footage when activity is detected.

Shinobi

Description: Shinobi is an open source CCTV software used for video surveillance and monitoring. It allows users to manage IP cameras, record footage, and view live streams. Shinobi has motion detection, email/SMS alerts, and user management features.

Key Features Comparison

ZoneMinder Features

• Live view and playback of IP cameras
• Motion detection and event notifications
• Continuous, scheduled, or motion-triggered recording
• Remote access via web browser or mobile app
• Support for a wide variety of IP cameras
• Open source and self-hosted (no vendor lock-in)
• Event-driven automation via hooks into other applications

Shinobi Features

• IP camera management
• Live video streaming
• Motion detection
• Video recording
• User management
• Email/SMS alerts

Pros & Cons Analysis

ZoneMinder

Pros

• Free and open source
• Self-hosted so you control your data
• Works with many different camera models
• Good community support
• Highly customizable and integrates well with other tools

Cons

• Can be complex to set up and manage
• Lacks some features of commercial NVR software
• Mobile app could be better
• Requires technical expertise to run server and manage cameras

Shinobi

Pros

• Open source
• Flexible platform
• Wide device support
• Customizable
• Self-hosted option

Cons

• Steep learning curve
• Requires technical expertise
• Limited support options
• Can be resource intensive

Pricing Comparison

ZoneMinder

• Open Source

Shinobi

• Open Source
• Self-Hosted