HomeAdvisor vs Thumbtack

Struggling to choose between HomeAdvisor and Thumbtack? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

HomeAdvisor is a Home & Family solution with tags like home-improvement, contractors, repair, maintenance.

It boasts features such as Allows homeowners to find prescreened, customer-rated home service professionals, Provides a large network of service professionals across hundreds of categories, Homeowners can read reviews, compare bids, and book appointments directly through the platform, Professionals are background checked and must meet eligibility requirements, Provides project cost guides and tools to help estimate project costs, Offers a Happiness Guarantee for homeowners if a project goes wrong and pros including Pre-vetted professionals, User reviews help find highly rated pros, Convenient booking and payment, Cost guides assist with budgeting, Large network of pros across many service categories.

On the other hand, Thumbtack is a Business & Commerce product tagged with local-services, home-services, professionals, contractors.

Its standout features include Allows customers to post projects and get quotes from local professionals, Large network of professionals from many service categories like home repair, events, lessons, etc, Customers can review profiles and ratings of professionals before hiring, Professionals can create detailed profiles showcasing their services, Built-in messaging system to communicate between customers and professionals, and it shines with pros like Makes it easy for customers to find and connect with qualified local professionals, Free for customers to post projects and get quotes, Wide selection of service professionals to choose from, Helps professionals get new customers and projects.

Feature	HomeAdvisor	Thumbtack
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Home & Family	Business & Commerce

Product Overview

HomeAdvisor

Description: HomeAdvisor is a home services platform that connects homeowners with prescreened, customer-rated service professionals for home repair, maintenance, and improvement projects. Homeowners can search and book local professionals directly through the HomeAdvisor website or mobile app.

Thumbtack

Description: Thumbtack is an online marketplace that connects customers with local professionals like plumbers, electricians, photographers, painters, and more. Customers describe their projects and receive customized quotes from professionals based on their job details. Professionals pay to bid on jobs but only pay when they win projects.

Key Features Comparison

HomeAdvisor Features

• Allows homeowners to find prescreened, customer-rated home service professionals
• Provides a large network of service professionals across hundreds of categories
• Homeowners can read reviews, compare bids, and book appointments directly through the platform
• Professionals are background checked and must meet eligibility requirements
• Provides project cost guides and tools to help estimate project costs
• Offers a Happiness Guarantee for homeowners if a project goes wrong

Thumbtack Features

• Allows customers to post projects and get quotes from local professionals
• Large network of professionals from many service categories like home repair, events, lessons, etc
• Customers can review profiles and ratings of professionals before hiring
• Professionals can create detailed profiles showcasing their services
• Built-in messaging system to communicate between customers and professionals

Pros & Cons Analysis

HomeAdvisor

Pros

• Pre-vetted professionals
• User reviews help find highly rated pros
• Convenient booking and payment
• Cost guides assist with budgeting
• Large network of pros across many service categories

Cons

• Some users report inconsistent quality of pros
• Not all pros available in all locations
• Additional fees charged to pros can increase project cost
• Limited ability to negotiate pricing with pros

Thumbtack

Pros

• Makes it easy for customers to find and connect with qualified local professionals
• Free for customers to post projects and get quotes
• Wide selection of service professionals to choose from
• Helps professionals get new customers and projects

Cons

• Professionals have to pay to bid on projects
• Customers may get an overwhelming number of bids to sift through
• Hard for new professionals to stand out with limited reviews/profile

Pricing Comparison

HomeAdvisor

• Free for homeowners
• Subscription-based for professionals

Thumbtack

• Freemium - Free for customers, paid for professionals