ICL Icon Extractor vs Greenfish Icon Editor Pro

Struggling to choose between ICL Icon Extractor and Greenfish Icon Editor Pro? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

ICL Icon Extractor is a File Management solution with tags like icon, image, extractor, exe, dll, icl.

It boasts features such as Extracts icons, cursors, and other image files from EXE, DLL, ICL files, Supports a wide range of image formats like ICO, CUR, BMP, GIF, JPG, PNG, Lets you preview and select specific images to extract, Batch extraction mode to extract images from multiple files, Simple and easy to use interface and pros including Free and open source, Fast extraction of images, Supports many file types and image formats, Easy to use with minimal setup, Lightweight and portable.

On the other hand, Greenfish Icon Editor Pro is a Photos & Graphics product tagged with icon-editor, image-editor, layers, effects, batch-processing, icon-libraries.

Its standout features include Supports various icon formats like ICO, ICNS, BMP, PNG, GIF, Allows editing individual icons in icon libraries, Provides layers support for advanced editing, Has a variety of tools like brushes, shapes, color fill, Allows applying effects like shadows, glows, blurs, Supports batch processing to edit multiple icons, Can create and manage custom icon libraries, Exports icons for different platforms like Windows, MacOS, iOS, Android, Provides both dark and light editing themes, and it shines with pros like Powerful icon and image editing capabilities, Supports many icon formats and platforms, Easy to use with intuitive interface, Lots of advanced editing tools and effects, Batch processing saves time, Custom icon libraries for organizing icons, Affordable one-time purchase price.

Feature	ICL Icon Extractor	Greenfish Icon Editor Pro
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	File Management	Photos & Graphics

Product Overview

ICL Icon Extractor

Description: ICL Icon Extractor is a free software that allows you to easily extract icons, cursors, and other image files from EXE, DLL, ICL, and other files. It has a simple interface that lets you open a file, select the images to extract, and save them.

Greenfish Icon Editor Pro

Description: Greenfish Icon Editor Pro is a powerful icon and image editing software for Windows. It allows designing, editing, and converting various icon and image formats. Key features include layers support, special effects, batch processing, icon libraries, and more.

Key Features Comparison

ICL Icon Extractor Features

• Extracts icons, cursors, and other image files from EXE, DLL, ICL files
• Supports a wide range of image formats like ICO, CUR, BMP, GIF, JPG, PNG
• Lets you preview and select specific images to extract
• Batch extraction mode to extract images from multiple files
• Simple and easy to use interface

Greenfish Icon Editor Pro Features

• Supports various icon formats like ICO, ICNS, BMP, PNG, GIF
• Allows editing individual icons in icon libraries
• Provides layers support for advanced editing
• Has a variety of tools like brushes, shapes, color fill
• Allows applying effects like shadows, glows, blurs
• Supports batch processing to edit multiple icons
• Can create and manage custom icon libraries
• Exports icons for different platforms like Windows, MacOS, iOS, Android
• Provides both dark and light editing themes

Pros & Cons Analysis

ICL Icon Extractor

Pros

• Free and open source
• Fast extraction of images
• Supports many file types and image formats
• Easy to use with minimal setup
• Lightweight and portable

Cons

• Limited to extracting images only
• No advanced customization options
• Basic interface with no themes or skins
• Does not extract other resources from files

Greenfish Icon Editor Pro

Pros

• Powerful icon and image editing capabilities
• Supports many icon formats and platforms
• Easy to use with intuitive interface
• Lots of advanced editing tools and effects
• Batch processing saves time
• Custom icon libraries for organizing icons
• Affordable one-time purchase price

Cons

• Lacks some very advanced editing features
• Occasional bugs and stability issues
• Exports are sometimes inconsistent
• No cloud sync for libraries
• Can be slow with very large icons

Pricing Comparison

ICL Icon Extractor

• Free

Greenfish Icon Editor Pro

• One-time Purchase