Skip to content

Icon Tool vs Material Maker

Professional comparison and analysis to help you choose the right software solution for your needs.

Icon Tool icon
Icon Tool
Material Maker icon
Material Maker

Icon Tool vs Material Maker: The Verdict

⚡ Summary:

Icon Tool: Icon Tool is a free icon editor for Windows that allows you to easily create, edit, and convert icons in various formats like ICO, PNG, ICNS and more. It has a simple interface with basic icon editing features like resize, crop, color adjustments, effects, and more.

Material Maker: Material Maker is a tool for generating custom PBR textures and materials for 3D rendering. It provides an intuitive node-based interface for creating textures like diffuse, roughness, normal maps and more from scratch.

Both tools serve their respective audiences. Compare the features, pricing, and user ratings above to determine which best fits your needs.

Last updated: May 2026 · Comparison by Sugggest Editorial Team

Feature Icon Tool Material Maker
Sugggest Score — —
Category Photos & Graphics Photos & Graphics
Pricing Open Source —

Product Overview

Icon Tool
Icon Tool

Description: Icon Tool is a free icon editor for Windows that allows you to easily create, edit, and convert icons in various formats like ICO, PNG, ICNS and more. It has a simple interface with basic icon editing features like resize, crop, color adjustments, effects, and more.

Type: software

Pricing: Open Source

Material Maker
Material Maker

Description: Material Maker is a tool for generating custom PBR textures and materials for 3D rendering. It provides an intuitive node-based interface for creating textures like diffuse, roughness, normal maps and more from scratch.

Type: software

Key Features Comparison

Icon Tool
Icon Tool Features
  • Edit and convert icons in various formats
  • Resize, crop, rotate, flip icons
  • Adjust colors, brightness, contrast
  • Add effects like shadows, glows
  • Supports ICO, ICNS, PNG, BMP formats
Material Maker
Material Maker Features
  • Node-based workflow for creating PBR materials
  • Generate textures like diffuse, roughness, normal maps
  • Supports common texture map formats like JPEG, PNG, TIFF
  • Can export materials for use in game engines like Unity, Unreal
  • Intuitive UI with drag and drop nodes
  • Comes with library of material nodes like wood, metal, fabric
  • Can create both 2D and 3D procedural textures
  • Has filter nodes for effects like blur, distort, tile
  • Works with common 3D model formats like OBJ, FBX, GLTF

Pros & Cons Analysis

Icon Tool
Icon Tool
Pros
  • Free and open source
  • Simple and easy to use interface
  • Supports multiple icon formats
  • Has basic editing tools for resizing, colors, effects
Cons
  • Limited advanced editing features
  • Cannot create icons from scratch
  • Fewer capabilities than paid icon editors
Material Maker
Material Maker
Pros
  • Powerful node workflow for ultimate control
  • Great for quickly mocking up materials
  • Huge library of material nodes
  • Exports to major game engines
  • Intuitive and easy to use interface
  • Can create high quality PBR materials
Cons
  • Node workflow has learning curve
  • Limited documentation and tutorials
  • No animation or physics support
  • Only focuses on materials, not modeling
  • Real-time viewport can be slow

Pricing Comparison

Icon Tool
Icon Tool
  • Open Source
Material Maker
Material Maker
  • Not listed

Related Comparisons

Substance Designer
vs Icon Tool vs Material Maker

Learn More About Each Product

Icon Tool
Icon Tool
Reviews, pricing & alternatives →
Material Maker
Material Maker
Reviews, pricing & alternatives →

Ready to Make Your Decision?

Explore more software comparisons and find the perfect solution for your needs

Icon Tool Alternatives
Material Maker Alternatives
Browse More Software