netdiscover vs WinMTR

Struggling to choose between netdiscover and WinMTR? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

netdiscover is a Network & Admin solution with tags like network, scanner, arp, discovery.

It boasts features such as Active and passive host discovery, Detects live hosts on a network by sending ARP requests, Prints IP address, MAC address and hostname of discovered devices, Can scan entire subnet or custom IP range, Lightweight and fast host discovery, Open source and cross-platform and pros including Easy to use with simple command line interface, Fast and efficient host discovery, Identifies active hosts accurately, Works on Linux, Mac and Windows, Free and open source.

On the other hand, WinMTR is a Network & Admin product tagged with troubleshooting, latency, packet-loss.

Its standout features include Traceroute tool to visualize network path, Real-time network monitoring, Latency and packet loss reporting, Hop-by-hop analysis, Graphical network topology mapping, Export data to text file, and it shines with pros like Free and open source, Simple and easy to use, Lightweight resource usage, Identifies network issues quickly, Works on all Windows platforms.

Feature	netdiscover	WinMTR
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Network & Admin	Network & Admin

Product Overview

netdiscover

Description: netdiscover is an open-source network scanner used to actively detect live hosts on a network. It sends ARP requests to identify active devices and prints the IP address, MAC address, and hostname if available.

WinMTR

Description: WinMTR is a free network diagnostics tool for Windows that provides real-time information about packet loss and latency between the local computer and a destination host. It's useful for troubleshooting network issues.

Key Features Comparison

netdiscover Features

• Active and passive host discovery
• Detects live hosts on a network by sending ARP requests
• Prints IP address, MAC address and hostname of discovered devices
• Can scan entire subnet or custom IP range
• Lightweight and fast host discovery
• Open source and cross-platform

WinMTR Features

• Traceroute tool to visualize network path
• Real-time network monitoring
• Latency and packet loss reporting
• Hop-by-hop analysis
• Graphical network topology mapping
• Export data to text file

Pros & Cons Analysis

netdiscover

Pros

• Easy to use with simple command line interface
• Fast and efficient host discovery
• Identifies active hosts accurately
• Works on Linux, Mac and Windows
• Free and open source

Cons

• Only does basic host discovery, no advanced scanning features
• May miss some hosts if ARP requests are blocked by firewall
• Requires root/admin privileges to scan network
• No official graphical user interface

WinMTR

Pros

• Free and open source
• Simple and easy to use
• Lightweight resource usage
• Identifies network issues quickly
• Works on all Windows platforms

Cons

• Limited reporting compared to advanced tools
• No customization or configuration options
• Basic interface lacks features
• Windows only, no Mac or Linux support

Pricing Comparison

netdiscover

• Open Source

WinMTR

• Free
• Open Source