Square Payroll vs Gusto

Struggling to choose between Square Payroll and Gusto? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Square Payroll is a Business & Commerce solution with tags like payroll, small-business, direct-deposit, tax-filing.

It boasts features such as Easy payroll setup, Payroll calculation, Direct deposit, Tax payments, Filing and pros including User-friendly interface, Integration with other Square products, Automatic tax calculations, Mobile app, Free payroll processing for one user.

On the other hand, Gusto is a Business & Commerce product tagged with payroll, hr, benefits, tax, onboarding.

Its standout features include Automated payroll processing, Direct deposit, Tax filings and payments, Employee self-service portal, Time tracking, PTO tracking, Employee onboarding, HR workflows, Benefits administration, ACA compliance, and it shines with pros like Easy to use interface, Automates payroll and taxes, Integrates with accounting software, Mobile app for employees, Robust HR features, Good customer support.

Feature	Square Payroll	Gusto
Overall Score	N/A	N/A
Primary Category	Business & Commerce	Business & Commerce

Product Overview

Square Payroll

Description: Square Payroll is a cloud-based payroll management software designed for small businesses. It allows easy payroll setup, calculation, direct deposit, tax payments, and filing.

Gusto

Description: Gusto is an all-in-one payroll, benefits, and human resources management software designed for small businesses. It automates payroll, calculations, tax filings and payments, provides HR tools for managing time-off, onboarding, and more.

Key Features Comparison

Square Payroll Features

• Easy payroll setup
• Payroll calculation
• Direct deposit
• Tax payments
• Filing

Gusto Features

• Automated payroll processing
• Direct deposit
• Tax filings and payments
• Employee self-service portal
• Time tracking
• PTO tracking
• Employee onboarding
• HR workflows
• Benefits administration
• ACA compliance

Pros & Cons Analysis

Square Payroll

Pros

• User-friendly interface
• Integration with other Square products
• Automatic tax calculations
• Mobile app
• Free payroll processing for one user

Cons

• Limited reporting
• Additional fees for multiple users
• Lack of advanced payroll features

Gusto

Pros

• Easy to use interface
• Automates payroll and taxes
• Integrates with accounting software
• Mobile app for employees
• Robust HR features
• Good customer support

Cons

• Can be pricey for very small businesses
• Limited customization options
• Third-party integrations cost extra
• No shift scheduling features

Pricing Comparison

Square Payroll

• Subscription-Based

Gusto

• Subscription-Based