Merkaartor vs StreetComplete

Struggling to choose between Merkaartor and StreetComplete? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Merkaartor is a Travel & Location solution with tags like openstreetmap, editor, gps, mapping.

It boasts features such as Allows editing OpenStreetMap data, Provides satellite imagery tracing tools, Supports GPS track importing, Has layer control for map data, Supports OpenStreetMap tagging schema, Has address and POI search tools and pros including Free and open source, Active development community, Integrates well with OpenStreetMap workflow, Many powerful editing tools, Cross-platform availability.

On the other hand, StreetComplete is a Travel & Location product tagged with open-source, mobile, gamification, crowdsourcing, mapping, openstreetmap.

Its standout features include Allows users to report missing map data, Gamifies the mapping process, Users can add street names, speed limits, building details, etc, Works on mobile devices, Uses OpenStreetMap data, and it shines with pros like Engaging way to improve OpenStreetMap data, Easy to use, Free and open source, Works offline, Large active user community.

To help you make an informed decision, we've compiled a comprehensive comparison of these two products, delving into their features, pros, cons, pricing, and more. Get ready to explore the nuances that set them apart and determine which one is the perfect fit for your requirements.

Merkaartor

Merkaartor

Merkaartor is an open source editor for OpenStreetMap, allowing users to view, edit, and upload OpenStreetMap data. It provides tools for tracing satellite imagery and importing GPS tracks.

Categories:
openstreetmap editor gps mapping

Merkaartor Features

  1. Allows editing OpenStreetMap data
  2. Provides satellite imagery tracing tools
  3. Supports GPS track importing
  4. Has layer control for map data
  5. Supports OpenStreetMap tagging schema
  6. Has address and POI search tools

Pricing

  • Open Source

Pros

Free and open source

Active development community

Integrates well with OpenStreetMap workflow

Many powerful editing tools

Cross-platform availability

Cons

Steep learning curve

Limited documentation/tutorials

Some stability issues

Lacks beginner-friendly features

Not as full-featured as proprietary options


StreetComplete

StreetComplete

StreetComplete is an open source mobile app that allows users to easily report missing information in OpenStreetMap, such as adding street names, speed limits, building details, etc. It aims to make OpenStreetMap mapping more engaging by gamifying the process.

Categories:
open-source mobile gamification crowdsourcing mapping openstreetmap

StreetComplete Features

  1. Allows users to report missing map data
  2. Gamifies the mapping process
  3. Users can add street names, speed limits, building details, etc
  4. Works on mobile devices
  5. Uses OpenStreetMap data

Pricing

  • Open Source
  • Free

Pros

Engaging way to improve OpenStreetMap data

Easy to use

Free and open source

Works offline

Large active user community

Cons

Limited to surveying data, not editing

Requires an OpenStreetMap account

Only available on Android and iOS

Some user interface issues

Requires a data connection for syncing