Potlatch vs Merkaartor

Struggling to choose between Potlatch and Merkaartor? Both products offer unique advantages, making it a tough decision.

Potlatch is a News & Books solution with tags like openstreetmap, editor, geospatial, crowdsourced, mapping.

It boasts features such as Edit OpenStreetMap data, Add/modify roads, buildings, points of interest, Integrated with OpenStreetMap, Real-time preview of edits, Undo/redo, Keyboard shortcuts, Tagging assistant, Presets for common map features and pros including Free to use, Open source, Web-based - no install required, Active development and user community, Good for new OpenStreetMap contributors, Integrates well with OpenStreetMap ecosystem.

On the other hand, Merkaartor is a Travel & Location product tagged with openstreetmap, editor, gps, mapping.

Its standout features include Allows editing OpenStreetMap data, Provides satellite imagery tracing tools, Supports GPS track importing, Has layer control for map data, Supports OpenStreetMap tagging schema, Has address and POI search tools, and it shines with pros like Free and open source, Active development community, Integrates well with OpenStreetMap workflow, Many powerful editing tools, Cross-platform availability.

To help you make an informed decision, we've compiled a comprehensive comparison of these two products, delving into their features, pros, cons, pricing, and more. Get ready to explore the nuances that set them apart and determine which one is the perfect fit for your requirements.

Potlatch

Potlatch

Potlatch is a free and open-source web-based editor for OpenStreetMap, a crowdsourced mapping project. It allows users to create, edit, and manipulate OpenStreetMap geospatial data.

Categories:
openstreetmap editor geospatial crowdsourced mapping

Potlatch Features

  1. Edit OpenStreetMap data
  2. Add/modify roads, buildings, points of interest
  3. Integrated with OpenStreetMap
  4. Real-time preview of edits
  5. Undo/redo
  6. Keyboard shortcuts
  7. Tagging assistant
  8. Presets for common map features

Pricing

  • Open Source

Pros

Free to use

Open source

Web-based - no install required

Active development and user community

Good for new OpenStreetMap contributors

Integrates well with OpenStreetMap ecosystem

Cons

Less powerful than desktop editors like JOSM

Limited customization options

Not ideal for bulk edits or imports

No offline editing capability


Merkaartor

Merkaartor

Merkaartor is an open source editor for OpenStreetMap, allowing users to view, edit, and upload OpenStreetMap data. It provides tools for tracing satellite imagery and importing GPS tracks.

Categories:
openstreetmap editor gps mapping

Merkaartor Features

  1. Allows editing OpenStreetMap data
  2. Provides satellite imagery tracing tools
  3. Supports GPS track importing
  4. Has layer control for map data
  5. Supports OpenStreetMap tagging schema
  6. Has address and POI search tools

Pricing

  • Open Source

Pros

Free and open source

Active development community

Integrates well with OpenStreetMap workflow

Many powerful editing tools

Cross-platform availability

Cons

Steep learning curve

Limited documentation/tutorials

Some stability issues

Lacks beginner-friendly features

Not as full-featured as proprietary options